Is this property overpriced?

See what similar homes actually sold for — not just the asking price. Used by 7,000+ Australians.

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3

2

2

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5 Paul Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

Days on Market

44 Days

Property Details
Sold History

Minutes To The Beach

THE ULTIMATE ENTERTAINER !...

House

430 m2

Listed: $1,750,000
Now: $1,700,000 -2.9%

Join 7,000+ Australians tracking property prices:

See how this property compares to the market:

No sold prices, we will add the information as we find it.

Tracked Umina Beach Properties

580

Median Listing Price

$1,230,000

Median Sold Price

$1,230,000

Listing to Sold Difference

$0

Try Our Maps

Spachus Professional

Disclaimer: The estimate price is for general information purposes only. While we use reasonable attempts to ensure the accuracy and completeness of the estimate, we make no representation or warranty in relation to it.

Top Agents for Umina Beach

David RoyDomain Property Group

Median Display Price: $1,275,000

Median Sold Price: $1,285,000

Christian FryBelle Property Killcare

Median Display Price: $990,000

Median Sold Price: $990,000

Nicole MannersJL Property Co

Median Display Price: $720,000

Median Sold Price: $686,500

Luke Schoonbeek

Luke SchoonbeekJL Property Co

Median Display Price: $990,000

Median Sold Price: $940,000

Yogesh Pudasaini

Yogesh PudasainiMcGrath Hornsby

Median Display Price: $600,000

Median Sold Price: $550,000

Suggested Properties

36 Priestman Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

36 Priestman Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

Listed: $1,740,000
Now: $1,675,000 (-3.7%)

3 Fishermans Parade, Daleys Point NSW 2257

3 Fishermans Parade, Daleys Point NSW 2257

Listed: $730,000
Now: $600,000 (-17.8%)

2/16 Nowack Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

2/16 Nowack Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

Listed: $1,725,000
Now: $1,685,000 (-2.3%)

3/147 Booker Bay Road, Booker Bay NSW 2257

3/147 Booker Bay Road, Booker Bay NSW 2257

Listed: $1,200,000
Now: $1,100,000 (-8.3%)

Recently Sold Properties

37 Greenhaven Drive, Umina Beach NSW 2257

37 Greenhaven Drive, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5

3

4

Listed: $1,390,000
Sold: $1,310,000 (-5.8%)

Sold by private treaty 20 Nov 2025

7/130 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

7/130 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

2

1

1

Listed: $975,000
Sold: $1,250,000 (28.2%)

Sold at auction 15 Nov 2025

2/175 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

2/175 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3

2

1

Listed: $1,250,000
Sold: $1,300,000 (4.0%)

Sold by private treaty 13 Nov 2025

89 Neera Road, Umina Beach NSW 2257

89 Neera Road, Umina Beach NSW 2257

4

2

4

Listed: $1,325,000
Sold: $1,250,000 (-5.7%)

Sold by private treaty 29 Oct 2025

53 Australia Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

53 Australia Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3

2

0

Listed: $1,275,000
Sold: $1,230,000 (-3.5%)

Sold by private treaty 24 Oct 2025

173 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

173 The Esplanade, Umina Beach NSW 2257

4

4

0

Listed: $3,250,000
Sold: $3,400,000 (4.6%)

Sold prior to auction 27 Oct 2025

55 Gwendolen Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

55 Gwendolen Avenue, Umina Beach NSW 2257

4

2

4

Listed: $1,950,000
Sold: $1,775,000 (-9.0%)

Sold by private treaty 15 Oct 2025

8 Timbertop Drive, Umina Beach NSW 2257

8 Timbertop Drive, Umina Beach NSW 2257

4

2

2

Listed: $1,100,000
Sold: $987,200 (-10.3%)

Sold by private treaty 9 Oct 2025

314 Ocean Beach Road, Umina Beach NSW 2257

314 Ocean Beach Road, Umina Beach NSW 2257

5

3

2

Listed: $1,350,000
Sold: $1,350,000 (0.0%)

Sold by private treaty 30 Sep 2025

3/156-158 West Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3/156-158 West Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3

2

1

Listed: $1,050,000
Sold: $1,130,000 (7.6%)

Sold by private treaty 26 Sep 2025

1/33 King Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

1/33 King Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

3

1

2

Listed: $889,000
Sold: $865,000 (-2.7%)

Sold by private treaty 23 Sep 2025

2/42 Berith Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

2/42 Berith Street, Umina Beach NSW 2257

2

1

1

Listed: $730,000
Sold: $755,000 (3.4%)

Sold by private treaty 17 Sep 2025

\